Narendra Modi was as soon as shunned by the U.S. In 2005, the then-chief minister of the Indian state of Gujarat was denied a diplomatic visa amid accusations he tacitly supported Hindu mobs throughout communal violence three years earlier that left greater than 1,000 folks, most of them Muslim, lifeless.
However he’s shunned no extra. On June 22, Washington will roll out the pink carpet for Modi, who will turn into simply the third world chief (after France’s Emmanuel Macron and South Korea’s Yoon Suk Yeol) to be invited by President Joe Biden for a state go to and dinner, the very best of diplomatic receptions sometimes reserved for under the closest of allies. That Biden has chosen to fete Modi on this approach is indicative of the “deep and shut partnership” between their two nations, the White Home mentioned in a statement, particularly on issues of overseas coverage. However it’s maybe additionally emblematic of the rising visibility and electoral heft of the Indian American group.
“Indian People are a key constituency and a key vote in a lot of swing states,” says Sara Sadhwani, an assistant professor of politics at Pomona Faculty and a senior researcher at AAPI Knowledge, which publishes demographic information and coverage analysis on Asian People.
With a inhabitants of practically 5 million, Indian People are the second-largest immigrant group and fastest-growing voting bloc within the U.S. right this moment. Their influence is obvious on the poll field, the place Indian People voted in record numbers through the 2020 presidential election. It’s also turning into more and more obvious within the halls of energy, from Congress (the place there are 5 Indian American lawmakers at present serving, up from just one a decade in the past) to the White Home (the place Kamala Harris, who’s biracial, made historical past as the primary Vice President of Indian heritage). Whereas each presidential contest since 2016 has featured not less than one Indian American candidate, 2024 is poised to be the primary race to function not less than two: Nikki Hayley, the daughter of Sikh immigrants from Punjab, and Vivek Ramaswamy, whose mother and father hail from Kerala.
Modi’s enduring recognition among the many diaspora
A supporter holds up U.S. and Indian nationwide flags as he assembles with a big crowd of individuals in Occasions Sq. to observe India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Madison Sq. Backyard speech simulcast on a large display in New York Metropolis on Sept. 28, 2014.
Supporters cheer President Donald Trump and Prime Minister Narendra Modi of India at an occasion in Houston known as “Howdy, Modi: Shared Desires, Shiny Futures” on Sept. 22, 2019.
Doug Mills—The New York Occasions/Redux
The Indian American group’s political affect has not been misplaced on Modi, who has leveraged its affect again and again. When the Prime Minister first got here to energy in 2014, he was obtained by 20,000 spectators at a sold-out occasion in New York’s Madison Sq. Backyard throughout a five-day go to to the U.S. It was the most important reception any overseas chief has obtained within the nation after the Pope. “That is India’s century,” Modi declared, sending the wildly enthusiastic crowd right into a frenzy.
In 2019, Modi as soon as once more obtained a jubilant reception with practically 50,000 spectators at a “Howdy Modi” rally in Houston.
A survey on Indian American attitudes performed by the Carnegie Endowment for Worldwide Peace and YouGov in 2020 discovered that Indian People held broadly favorable views of Modi, with practically half approving of his efficiency as Prime Minister. Milan Vaishnav, director of the South Asia Program at Carnegie, says that this may be as a result of the Indian diaspora sees Modi as “reclaiming India’s rightful standing on the worldwide scene.”
“India is now perceived to be each huge and important to geopolitics,” Vaishnav provides. Whether or not it’s internet hosting the G-20, being feted on the state dinner by President Biden, and even sustaining cordial relations with Vladimir Putin, he says that “many Indian diaspora members view this as an indication that India is again and experiencing a interval of resurgence.”
The assist for Modi comes although whereas Indian People are hardly a monolith, they have an inclination to vote for Democrats, reasonably than Republicans who extra carefully align with Modi’s right-wing Bharatiya Janata Occasion. As many as 74% of Indian American voters are thought to have backed Biden in 2020, in response to a 2022 survey by AAPI Data, in comparison with simply 15% supporting Donald Trump.
Whereas Biden’s welcoming of Modi is broadly seen within the context of Washington hoping to strike protection offers with New Delhi (most analysts inform TIME the rationale for the go to might be distilled to at least one phrase—China—owing to the indispensable position of India in U.S. efforts to discourage Chinese language aggression), it’s additionally recognizing Modi’s recognition amongst a key American voting bloc. “In a time when the nation has elections determined by 4 states and a margin of some p.c or much less, each group actually issues,” says Neil Makhija, the president of Indian American Influence advocacy group. “Ours actually confirmed up in a big approach for [Biden] in Georgia, in Pennsylvania, in Arizona.”
Nonetheless, the Republican Occasion sees Indian People as a “pure constituency,” Vaishnav says. “They’re well-off, and so they’re enterprise oriented. They care about low taxes, low regulation, and entrepreneurship, and so they’re socially conservative. So I don’t assume it’s a gaggle that the Democratic Occasion goes to take without any consideration.”
A “very awkward” dilemma
Protestors stage an illustration in opposition to Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi throughout the road from Madison Sq. Backyard, the place Modi spoke to a crowd from the Indian-American group, Sept. 28, 2014, in New York.
Modi’s state go to additionally poses a strategic problem to Biden. As a candidate, the U.S. President made defending human rights and democracy a cornerstone of his overseas coverage agenda. Critics argue that his embrace of Modi, who over his two phrases as Prime Minister has overseen important democratic backsliding in India, is doing simply the other.
The controversial Indian chief—who’s poised to win his third time period subsequent yr—has been accused of aggressively championing a Hindu-nationalist agenda that critics say reinvents the very thought of India as a pluralist, secular democracy to a spiritual, nationalist autocracy. Beneath Modi’s management, India has handed discriminatory legal guidelines which have alienated practically 200 million Muslims; squashed dissent by jailing journalists, activists, and civil society organizations; and exercised judicial affect in opposition to his political opponents (notably, Rahul Gandhi, the de facto chief and scion of the Gandhi-Nehru household on the helm of the opposition Congress Occasion).
The U.S. has taken observe. The State Division’s annual Non secular Freedom Report, a survey of non secular freedoms all over the world, has expressed a number of concerns over India in recent times. It was notable that in contrast to final yr, U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken made no point out of India in his speech this yr, which analysts noticed as a transfer to maintain U.S.-India relations pleasant forward of Modi’s go to.
However in response to Audrey Truschke, an affiliate professor of South Asian historical past at Rutgers College and a vocal critic of Modi’s Hindu nationalist base, the choice to host Modi exhibits that the “Biden administration doesn’t care about human rights in India. In the event that they did, there’s completely no approach that they might be internet hosting Modi proper now.”
“It’s very awkward for the administration,” provides Michael Kugelman, the director of the South Asia Institute on the Wilson Middle think-tank in Washington, D.C. “The strategic imperatives of partnership restrict the choices for the administration to convey consideration to this problem—particularly publicly, provided that this Indian authorities doesn’t take kindly to any kind of exterior criticism of its inside insurance policies.” The highest precedence for the administration, he says, will likely be to “keep away from any drama.”
Whereas the White Home might wish to preserve the go to as anodyne as attainable, the identical doesn’t look like the case for the Indian American group at massive. Within the run as much as Modi’s go to, pro-Modi teams have organized “Unity” marches in practically 20 American cities on June 18, whereas these against Modi’s presence plan to stage a rally close to the White Home to coincide along with his arrival on June 22.
In an open letter drafted by Hindus for Human Rights, a Washington D.C.-based advocacy group, a number of Indian People, human rights advocates, and anxious allies have additionally urged Biden to “push again” in opposition to the Indian authorities’s “escalating assaults on human rights and democracy.”
By honoring Modi, Truschke warns that the White Home may inadvertently encourage communal violence throughout the Indian American group. “This can make Hindu nationalist teams really feel much more emboldened within the U.S.,” says Truschke, who herself has been on the receiving end of threats from far-right Hindu nationalists.
Extra Should-Reads From TIME